Thread subject: FunTibia - Have fun with us! :: Results FunTibia Birth Contests 2012

Posted by Kariel Win on 11 July 2012 22:18:29
#1

Congratulations to all participants for their efforts and creativity. :)

Here are the winners: :D

Best Friend Contest:

1st Place: Blade - Gang of blades-
i45.tinypic.com/amr67a.jpg

Character: Blade Lottus
World: Magera
City: Venore


2nd Place: jeffstarchips - Grim Reaper-
img811.imageshack.us/img811/6398/funtibia2.jpg

Char: Black Scofield
World: Harmonia
City: Thais



3rd Place:
Dahlia - Giant painter spider -
i46.tinypic.com/212e529.jpg

Char: Dahlia
World: Lunara
City: Liberty Bay


For the winners please confirm your information.



Choose a present Contest:


1st Place:
User: Fenelez
Char: Warrior
World: Antica
City: Venore

2nd Place:
User: luminis
Char: Luminis Et Anima
World: Unitera
City: Ab'Dendriel

3rd Place:
User: Spudmuffin
Char: Spuddsy
World: Honera
City: Liberty Bay

For the winners please confirm your information.


Thanks for everybody that joined the contest
Have Fun!
Kariel Win

Edited by Kariel Win on 17 July 2012 22:15:45

Posted by abiston on 12 July 2012 01:47:50
#2

I was sooooooooooooo trolled now! I opened the thread 100% sure that I would see the winners. DD:

Hope you release it soon! :)

Posted by Elais on 12 July 2012 03:24:27
#3

ahuaaahha the same happened to me!

Indeed! this is a tricky thread made by evul Kariel! XDDD

Posted by abiston on 12 July 2012 07:19:56
#4

I deserve a nightmare doll due to my semi heart-attack :P

Posted by Kariel Win on 12 July 2012 19:24:58
#5

bump:D

Posted by abiston on 12 July 2012 20:37:02
#6

The winners of Best Friend Contest are really good, but I cannot say the same about the 1st place of Choose a present Contest. In my opinion, luminis and Spudmuffin's submissions were far much better than Fenelez's.

Anyway, congratulations to all the winners!

Posted by Kariel Win on 12 July 2012 20:45:59
#7

abiston wrote:
The winners of Best Friend Contest are really good, but I cannot say the same about the 1st place of Choose a present Contest. In my opinion, luminis and Spudmuffin's submissions were far much better than Fenelez's.

Anyway, congratulations to all the winners!


So you didn't read the contest description...
It was made a lottery

Posted by abiston on 12 July 2012 21:02:35
#8

Kariel Win wrote:
abiston wrote:
The winners of Best Friend Contest are really good, but I cannot say the same about the 1st place of Choose a present Contest. In my opinion, luminis and Spudmuffin's submissions were far much better than Fenelez's.

Anyway, congratulations to all the winners!


So you didn't read the contest description...
It was made a lottery


Actually I misinterpreted it. I thought there would be prizes for the best submissions + a lottery for some participants (I had already seen something similar to that in other contests).

Posted by Trishula on 12 July 2012 21:14:52
#9

What exactly do you define as plagiarism? Because the first place is a total copy of cipsoft and LiDao's artwork

images3.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20081210161526/tibia/en/images/3/38/Nightmare.jpg


funtibia.com/images/photoalbum/album_9/dread_doll_by_lidao-d38qv7p_t2.jpg


Posted by luminis on 12 July 2012 21:21:52
#10

Ty very much :D

Good job all winners :D

im publish my city and server? hmm... dont remember but... i'am:

Golden Emblem Rune: Magic Wall

Luminis Et Anima
Unitera
Ab'dendriel

Kariel, 4 u :* ;)

Edited by luminis on 12 July 2012 21:27:50

Posted by Kariel Win on 12 July 2012 21:30:00
#11

Example: You will not make your own character, so you can use something that already exists on Tibia. So let’s say you think the monster Hydra it’s a good to be a new friend to our mascot, so you can make your art based on Hydra designs. And don’t forget to say why you choose the Hydra.


You could use monsters/item that already exists on game and draw in your way.

i50.tinypic.com/a41m4z.jpg

Posted by quike87 on 12 July 2012 23:19:55
#12

Seriously are those the winners?! I'm not with it, the only one who deserves the price here is Torn teddy pic, 'cause it is original being broke with the blades.. but to start, first place for me it is totally a pilagrism and, you told we're talking about Tibia graphics, you said on the rules, I don't see any Tibia graphics on that pic.. anyway you're who decided it so... but 2nd place a carnivor plant copied totally from Super Mario game? OMG, on my opinion it is totally wrong to give that item to a COPY.

Posted by quike87 on 12 July 2012 23:22:28
#13

And if you think just change a little bit the face from original cipsoft pic it is draw it by your own way... I give +1 to guy who also told about that!

Posted by Kariel Win on 13 July 2012 00:05:26
#14

This was not a contest to see who is the best designer, who made the best picture.

Posted by Ameriov on 13 July 2012 00:10:11
#15

Anyway, gratz for the winners!

Posted by blade on 13 July 2012 01:12:16
#16

Thanks guys, i´m so happy!
And congratulations everyone, it was a nice contest.
I confirm my information as in the 1st post

Character: Blade Lottus
World: Magera
City: Venore

Btw, the rune emblem i choose is Sudden Death rune.

@ppl that are accusing me of plagiarism: I didn´t copy anything, the ideas were mine, and the drawings too, they were made from a blank document, they were scratched, and it took a long time to design it, paint it, and think about it. Of course i used some inspiration of cipsoft artwork and LiDao, which are works that i admire, but that does not mean that it was plagiarism, it was just simple references, mainly on anatomy. I can make the upload of the psd files. My work is valid

Posted by Mack Kard on 13 July 2012 02:04:53
#17

Wao! really amazed by the winners of "Best Friend Contest"!
really didn't believe that none of those three would win xD anyway ... Congratulations to all winners!
and to avoid further disagreement with the "Choose a present Contest" why not add the link on the lottery!

Again... Congratulations to all winners!
and for everyone else, good luck for next! :3

Posted by Luzei on 13 July 2012 02:42:07
#18

Hey!
Congratulations everyone.

edit: wops. nvm yes, my info was correct.

Edited by Luzei on 13 July 2012 02:53:54

Posted by Luzei on 13 July 2012 03:03:12
#19

quike87 wrote:
Seriously are those the winners?! I'm not with it, the only one who deserves the price here is Torn teddy pic, 'cause it is original being broke with the blades.. but to start, first place for me it is totally a pilagrism and, you told we're talking about Tibia graphics, you said on the rules, I don't see any Tibia graphics on that pic.. anyway you're who decided it so... but 2nd place a carnivor plant copied totally from Super Mario game? OMG, on my opinion it is totally wrong to give that item to a COPY.


About the 1st place. ( BLADE )
Is not plagiarism.
I agree with Kariel~
Example: You will not make your own character, so you can use something that already exists on Tibia. So let’s say you think the monster Hydra it’s a good to be a new friend to our mascot, so you can make your art based on Hydra designs. And don’t forget to say why you choose the Hydra.

The work was pretty good and the idea aswell.
btw congratulations.

But...
the second place? really?


【ツ】The item has to be made by you! - any kind of plagiarism is not allowed

Plagiarize [plagiary] : to steal and pass off (the ideas or words of another) as one's own : use (a created production) without crediting the source vi: to commit literary theft: present as new and original an idea or product derived from an existing source - pla·gia·riz·er n

I kinda agree with the guy I quoted, a "carnivor plant copied totally from Super Mario game? Omg", he just added the body of THE POKEMON "BELLSPROUT"
[url]http://img.hardcore-gamer.net/tienda/images/merch/nintendo/peluche_mario_bros_corgi_piranha_pete.jpg
[/url]

''.trimlink('http://www.deviantart.com/download/171643402/Singing_Bellsprout_by_sindytu.jpg', 20).(strlen('http://www.deviantart.com/download/171643402/Singing_Bellsprout_by_sindytu.jpg')>30?substr('http://www.deviantart.com/download/171643402/Singing_Bellsprout_by_sindytu.jpg', strlen('http://www.deviantart.com/download/171643402/Singing_Bellsprout_by_sindytu.jpg')-10, strlen('http://www.deviantart.com/download/171643402/Singing_Bellsprout_by_sindytu.jpg')):'').''

You can't deny thats plagiarism.

and the rules said:
【ツ】Remember that we are a Tibia fansite ;P (so don’t use graphics from other games)

He used another graphic games (Super Mario~)

_
There are a lot of good ideas, is not really fair that the Mario plant won. I think someone else deserves a chance. We should talk it with cipsoft or so and see what they say?

Is not fair... :(

Edited by Luzei on 13 July 2012 03:10:01

Posted by quike87 on 13 July 2012 03:34:47
#20

Thanks Luzei to be with me on it, 'cause is totally crazy that guy won... TOTALLY... I think is is totally trick...
Anyway, nice work the the judges! They said it's getting harder to get a choice... Yes, sure.

Posted by Trishula on 13 July 2012 04:00:50
#21

There is a big difference between using an artwork as inspiration and doing a very poorly copy of the original one. If you google "plagiarism art" Just check what you will get!
2.bp.blogspot.com/-BESUNPlmhio/TvG2Wayz3BI/AAAAAAAAAL8/c_FkdZZve4I/s1600/00.jpg


Now comparing your piece to Lidao's or cip's you can clearly see you just copied those! I believe the Carnivore Plant deserves to win first place no doubt. I'm not doing this because I want to win, I never even posted the artwork I did for the contest, for the same reason why I'm posting this. I'm sick of taking part on contests that give awards to people who don't deserve.

i174.photobucket.com/albums/w87/vvdealmeida/amr67acopy.jpg

Posted by Kariel Win on 13 July 2012 05:08:25
#22

When we said about plagiarize, we mean that we don't want to ppl get a work that already exists and say that is made be you.

Posted by Trishula on 13 July 2012 06:20:20
#23

Then that would not be plagiarism, it would be stealing. Maybe you could be more serious about your contests, or at least have a clue of what you say.

Posted by Kariel Win on 13 July 2012 08:02:23
#24

Trishula wrote:
Then that would not be plagiarism, it would be stealing. Maybe you could be more serious about your contests, or at least have a clue of what you say.


If you not happy with the word plagiarism and prefer the word steal, no problem. We use in a way the you understand better.
Next time I use the word steal, thx for the advice.

Posted by Shengso on 13 July 2012 11:44:16
#25

Still not enough for my curiosity! :p
Could you post the lottery list?

Posted by quike87 on 13 July 2012 13:17:15
#26

+1 to serousity on the contests. I still thiking it's just tricked, anyway... Your idea about plagiarism it's not right, check what this mate post on his forum about what does mean plagiarism... totally the same. When I saw that picture first time I thought it won't ranked 'cause of plagiarism...
Also what I gotta say about give grim reaper pic 2nd place have no sense for me. I mean, a couple of hours ago was the super mario/pokemon plagiarism who got the second price, and torn teddy was on 3rd price. So how it is possible to get another one as a 2nd place? If you ranked torn teddy after your lovely carnivor plant, Torn teddy now should be on second place, 'cause why wasn't grim reaper at 3rd place? THIS CONTEST SEEMS TOTALLY TRICKED BY ADMINISTRATORS!

Posted by abistral on 13 July 2012 14:27:03
#27

I agree in part with some coments posted up.
Anyways was a funny contest and some works were amazing and others just made me laugh because some were so ''rare'' or ''stupid'' xD :D

Congratulations to winners!

Edited by abistral on 13 July 2012 14:28:43

Posted by Trishula on 13 July 2012 17:08:24
#28

Kariel Win wrote:
Trishula wrote:
Then that would not be plagiarism, it would be stealing. Maybe you could be more serious about your contests, or at least have a clue of what you say.


If you not happy with the word plagiarism and prefer the word steal, no problem. We use in a way the you understand better.
Next time I use the word steal, thx for the advice.

See, this is exactly what I meant when I said "be serious about your contests".
You should focus on doing the right thing NOW! Don't try to fool us saying next time it will be different. In the contests description you used the word plagiarism, therefore it is prohibited!!!!

Follow YOUR RULES!!! And do the right thing, prove us that your website is not a fraud and that you take YOUR!!! OWN WORDS seriously!

Posted by Kariel Win on 13 July 2012 17:23:35
#29

Sorry for who is crying but the results will not change.

The lottery was made on Tibiopedia:
http://tibiopedia.pl/tools/lottery/10390
Lottery

Posted by Shengso on 13 July 2012 18:33:39
#30

Tbh, you shouldn't be surprised that there are so many complains.
For Example:

Lottery tickets - 93

Application - 90 or less(94 replies in thread, at least 4 were wrote by you so they are not applications)

Also, not everyone should get a ticket.
"【ツ】The best answers will win a ticket to our lottery."

Lottery link was given away after it was drawn, not before.
Lottery list should be given before lottery was drawn to make yourself reliable.

As you can see, it's seriously looks like fake; p

Posted by Kariel Win on 13 July 2012 18:37:24
#31

Shengso wrote:
Tbh, you shouldn't be surprised that there are so many complains.
For Example:

Lottery tickets - 93

Application - 90 or less(94 replies in thread, at least 4 were wrote by you so they are not applications)

Also, not everyone should get a ticket.
"【ツ】The best answers will win a ticket to our lottery."

Lottery link was given away after it was drawn, not before.
Lottery list should be given before lottery was drawn to make yourself reliable.

As you can see, it's seriously looks like fake; p



The answers that was not valid I deleted the posts.

Posted by Shengso on 13 July 2012 18:38:47
#32

Kariel Win wrote:

The answers that was not valid I deleted the posts.


Since they were not valid, why they got tickets? ;p

Edited by Kariel Win on 13 July 2012 18:43:26

Posted by Kariel Win on 13 July 2012 18:44:19
#33

Shengso wrote:
Kariel Win wrote:

The answers that was not valid I deleted the posts.


Since they were not valid, why they got tickets? ;p


They didnt won tickets. We had more than 100+ posts.
You can see that only 93 got tickets.

Posted by Shengso on 13 July 2012 18:50:14
#34

Kariel Win wrote:
They didnt won tickets. We had more than 100+ posts.
You can see that only 93 got tickets.


You had more then 100 posts, ok.
You deleted people who didn't valid to lottery, from what i can see in contest thread it makes 90 or less people.
So still, why 93 tickets?

@Edit
I will try to make it clear.

"Choose a present" Contest FunTibia 2012 (Page: 1 2 3 4 5)
Replies: 93(+1 as thread-made post)

Your posts- #1, #2, #3, #94 and possibly more.

94 - 4 = 90
tickets - 93

wtf?

Edited by Shengso on 13 July 2012 18:54:18

Posted by Luzei on 13 July 2012 19:18:28
#35

waaaaaaaaaaat!
so the plant got disqualified and im still 3rd? doesnt makes sense.

Contests are not like that you cant put another one there, the third place automatically goes to second place. This is so unfair guys..

Posted by quike87 on 13 July 2012 19:23:35
#36

I AM TELLING IT, CONTEST IS TRICKED BY ADMINISTRATORS. THERE ARE NO SENSE ON WHAT THEY ARE DOING!

Posted by quike87 on 13 July 2012 19:25:27
#37

What Luzei says it is totally true, I agree if you wanna give 3rd place to the grims reamper, but buddies don't make strange things... That's not serious.

Posted by Kariel Win on 13 July 2012 19:31:47
#38

still missing:

Spudmuffin and Black Scofield

choose their runes so I can send the prizes to everybody.

Posted by Kariel Win on 13 July 2012 19:40:59
#39

@Luzei

Don't think I just change the 2nd place for a new person.
We evaluted the results, accepted that the 2nd place was not original and looks a plant from Mario game.
After the new evaluation you got 3rd place again.

Posted by Luzei on 13 July 2012 19:48:24
#40

So you evaluated the new results in 1 day after the original ones took you like 1 week?, This doesnt makes sense

is like hmm a president wins, then he dies, obviously OBVIOUSLY the second president is going to be the first one now you cant put another one.

Feels this contest is not serious.

Posted by Kariel Win on 13 July 2012 19:50:05
#41

Luzei wrote:
So you evaluated the new results in 1 day after the original ones took you like 1 week?, This doesnt makes sense

is like hmm a president wins, then he dies, obviously OBVIOUSLY the second president is going to be the first one now you cant put another one.

Feels this contest is not serious.


Of course not. We just evaluated the top 5 we had.
If you not happy with the 3rd place tell me now. I can still change the 3rd place and give for the user that was 4rd place.

Posted by Luzei on 13 July 2012 19:52:14
#42

I talked with some ADMIN of other PROMOTED FANSITE,
When you set up winners you have
1.
2.
3.
4~
and even 5
so in case someone gets disqualified they go up (3rd takes 2nd, 4rth takes 3rd etc)

This is a joke
You cant say you re evaluate
then you shouldnt have posted the results if you werent SURE
this is unfair unfair unfair unfair unfair.
and very disrespectful.

Posted by Kariel Win on 13 July 2012 19:57:33
#43

Before the people ask.

Here is the new 3rd place if the actual give up.

Dahlia
i46.tinypic.com/212e529.jpg
Char: Dahlia
World: Lunara
City:Liberty Bay

As the people saw, I'm not like some other fansites. I don't have any problems in change the results.
I'm a player too and I already join contests in others fansites and I know what is feel that something is unfair. Always will have the ppl who like and who don't.

Posted by Luzei on 13 July 2012 20:01:26
#44

ofc im NOT giving up my "3rd place".
I hope cip looks into this.
You are being disrespectful :/

Posted by Kariel Win on 13 July 2012 20:07:44
#45

Cip already know what I'm doing.
If you feel that I'm being rude, sorry about that.
I just don't want spam here.

Posted by Trishula on 13 July 2012 20:08:14
#46

Luzei, this is so not fair, I sent an e-mail to cipsoft about your case and thte first place fraud, you should all do the same. Send the e-mail to fansites@tibia.com

Posted by James Dark on 13 July 2012 20:27:38
#47

well actualy i am with the other guys there was so many amanzing post and you choose first such a ru.... as second place then just change it agains another second place instand of put the furth place on third and third on second like it should be and ever is on all other contests (not only tibia related contests)
and to the first place it realy looks 99% same as the pics from cipsoft i mean taking it as insperation is something different then copying nearly orginal

but well looks like here is something wrong but players cant do much cipsoft need put their eyes themself in this contest otherwise it wont get changed at all

Posted by James Dark on 13 July 2012 20:30:29
#48

why doesnt you let the users choose who get place 1 2 and 3 this would be more fair

ya i know ppl can make 100000000 accs but well there everyone see at least how many ppl voted for witch pic

Posted by Kariel Win on 13 July 2012 20:44:32
#49

James Dark wrote:
why doesnt you let the users choose who get place 1 2 and 3 this would be more fair

ya i know ppl can make 100000000 accs but well there everyone see at least how many ppl voted for witch pic


Exact, and this will never happen, there will be a spam of accs being created. And Is clear that everyone will vote for their own work:P

Posted by James Dark on 13 July 2012 20:50:47
#50

well but you could say the accounts that was made while the contest runed cant make a choose or so then it would be possible

Posted by Shengso on 13 July 2012 21:36:58
#51

Shengso wrote:

You had more then 100 posts, ok.
You deleted people who didn't valid to lottery, from what i can see in contest thread it makes 90 or less people.
So still, why 93 tickets?

@Edit
I will try to make it clear.

"Choose a present" Contest FunTibia 2012 (Page: 1 2 3 4 5)
Replies: 93(+1 as thread-made post)

Your posts- #1, #2, #3, #94 and possibly more.

94 - 4 = 90
tickets - 93

wtf?


Why did i get ignored?

@Edit
Also, why making two lotteries and chosing later one?

http://tibiopedia.pl/tools/lottery/10389
http://tibiopedia.pl/tools/lottery/10390

Edited by Shengso on 13 July 2012 22:21:35

Posted by Kariel Win on 13 July 2012 22:56:23
#52

Shengso wrote:
Shengso wrote:

You had more then 100 posts, ok.
You deleted people who didn't valid to lottery, from what i can see in contest thread it makes 90 or less people.
So still, why 93 tickets?

@Edit
I will try to make it clear.

"Choose a present" Contest FunTibia 2012 (Page: 1 2 3 4 5)
Replies: 93(+1 as thread-made post)

Your posts- #1, #2, #3, #94 and possibly more.

94 - 4 = 90
tickets - 93

wtf?


Why did i get ignored?

@Edit
Also, why making two lotteries and chosing later one?

http://tibiopedia.pl/tools/lottery/10389
http://tibiopedia.pl/tools/lottery/10390


You didn't got ignored. You got a ticket number #80.

The winners are the numbers
1 #46
2 #84
3 #19


The number #3 it a post made be me. And would be no sense for I make a contest and I win the lottery LoL
So we talked with Cipsoft and we decided to make a new lotto.

Posted by Kariel Win on 13 July 2012 23:20:25
#53

Results(full list)

Judge 01:
1. Blade - Gang of blades-------10 points
2. Abistral - Unead Cavebear----08 points
3. Abiston - Undead Jester------05 points
4. Zexmura - Gozzler------------03 points
5. Luzei - Tornteddy------------02 points

Judge 02:
1. deusasorcererops-------------10 points
2. Dahlia-----------------------08 points
3. Lady Tynha-------------------05 points
4. Elais------------------------03 points
5. Trishula---------------------02 points

Judge 03:
1. jeffstarchips----------------10 points
2. Luzei------------------------08 points
3. Blade------------------------05 points
4. Elais------------------------03 points
5. Dahlia-----------------------02 points
_________________________________________

1. Blade - Gang of blades-------15 points
2. deusasorcererops-------------10 points*
___jeffstarchips----------------10 points
___Luzei------------------------10 points*
___Dahlia-----------------------10 points
6. Abistral - Unead Cavebear----08 points
7. Elais------------------------06 points
8. Abiston - Undead Jester------05 points
___Lady Tynha-------------------05 points
10. Zexmura - Gozzler------------03 points
11. Trishula---------------------02 points

*disqualified

Edited by Kariel Win on 17 July 2012 22:19:23

Posted by Zuthur on 13 July 2012 23:38:16
#54

I don't really see how that list of votes changes anything... what are you trying to prove? you still had Luzei on the third place and she should go up to second. B)

Posted by Kariel Win on 13 July 2012 23:52:00
#55

Zuthur wrote:
I don't really see how that list of votes changes anything... what are you trying to prove? you still had Luzei on the third place and she should go up to second. B)


I don't know if you blind or something
but in the "old" list Luzei is on 4rd place.

Also don't need to create new accounts, just use your main acc.

Some people asked for the full list so I posted.

Posted by Kariel Win on 13 July 2012 23:56:11
#56

Winner gonna love
Humans will accept
Haters gonna hate


Prize list sent.

For the haters on the next contests please make me the favor for not join ;)

For the FunTibians hold on, that we will have more contests still this year!!!

Thanks for everybody that join the contests and had fun!
:D

Posted by lekiro on 14 July 2012 00:05:52
#57

Why did the "old" 4th place even got a prize to begin with?

Posted by Moon Day on 14 July 2012 00:19:14
#58

Hey Kariel, i just want to know why did my post got deleted?

On the Choose a present contest

Posted by Elais on 14 July 2012 01:22:16
#59

WOHOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

I was in the 7º place of the list!!! lolololol XD

@thread:

qu messy at the moment of readin the posts.

move on and keep playin alright.

Edited by Elais on 14 July 2012 01:30:09

Posted by Trishula on 14 July 2012 02:06:18
#60

I didn't find a right place to post this, but why is my warn level 2? What wrong have a done? Are we not allowed free speech? Did I offend someone? The one being unreasonable here isn't me! It's sad seeing contests being held this way. I don't want to accuse the fansite administrator of anything. What I did in this thread was to try straighten things up! So YOU wouldn't look bad. This is your fansite and your reputation and not only in my eyes (as we can see MANY complains) this contest was weird and badly handed. Plus you shouldnt treat accusations made my members in such a childish way. Many people put alot of effort in this contest and the least they want is to be treated with respect.

Posted by Kariel Win on 14 July 2012 03:14:43
#61

Everybody is allowed to give your opinions since it be in a constructive way. What some people trying to do is to make bad advertisements about me or the fansite, and as adm I can't tolerate it. I don't make the things alone, have a team behind me that is envolved and together with cipsoft. I'm only the person who is infront to give the clarification. With that, I know that some people may think that the things done was made only by me, since I'm the only one who is talking. For the ppl who got warnings the reason are: spamming, making bad advertisements about the fansite or a person. The rules that we have on fansite are the same of Tibia.com.
The results will continue. The only thing that may change will be the 3rd place on the "Best friend" contest.

Posted by deusasorcererops on 14 July 2012 03:18:26
#62

It's So unfair.
:(
I was in first, and before un second...
annnnd I lose

I want cry :'(

Is UNFAIR

Posted by Tala The Homeless on 14 July 2012 03:35:17
#63

Seems I won 2th place on ''1st'' lottery draw, However I suppose it is pointless to complain about it?


because this contest seems unfair and corrupted in my eyes by read all posts, However. I call it ''hilarious'' that I ''win'' for 1st time after joined probely over 40 contest without win anything, But that is my kind of luck.


Quite disappointed but as I said earlier, Bet it is useless to complain about it by read all other people that have posted.

Edited by Tala The Homeless on 14 July 2012 03:36:53

Posted by James Dark on 14 July 2012 07:00:05
#64

just wondering couse i didnt even got 1 point what was wrong with my pic?
so i know it for next time

or was i instandly kicked couse there was a nightmare already on "band of blades" that wouldnt be nice -.-

Edited by James Dark on 14 July 2012 07:01:06

Posted by Kariel Win on 14 July 2012 07:29:10
#65

James Dark wrote:
just wondering couse i didnt even got 1 point what was wrong with my pic?
so i know it for next time

or was i instandly kicked couse there was a nightmare already on "band of blades" that wouldnt be nice -.-


The judges choose their top 5
for the 1st place they receive 10 points etc...
you pic didn't enter on top 5 thats why you didnt won points

Posted by Mack Kard on 14 July 2012 08:06:39
#66

Only are comments and i hope you can clarify


1.-
the name of the contest is:
Best Friend Contest...
the first place is... a "Gang"

if you can search the definition...
example "wikipedia"
you can found
"Best friend, someone (singular) with whom one shares the strongest possible kind of friendship "

so idk how 3 Creatures are in singular definition?



2.-
if the second was disqualified. why not the third change to that position? why appeared a 2nd new place?
taking scores and their way of seeing things, in any case the third should have been Jeffstarchips and not Luzei from the beginning.



3.-In the lottery, if you had a problem in the first lottery because you win a prize, why in the second lottery you wont eliminated your posts?




*I know this don't give me a place or a gift but only want to know explanations.

Posted by Arkindrakin on 14 July 2012 10:07:33
#67

Mack Kard wrote:
Only are comments and i hope you can clarify


1.-
the name of the contest is:
Best Friend Contest...
the first place is... a "Gang"

if you can search the definition...
example "wikipedia"
you can found
"Best friend, someone (singular) with whom one shares the strongest possible kind of friendship "

so idk how 3 Creatures are in singular definition?



2.-
if the second was disqualified. why not the third change to that position? why appeared a 2nd new place?
taking scores and their way of seeing things, in any case the third should have been Jeffstarchips and not Luzei from the beginning.



3.-In the lottery, if you had a problem in the first lottery because you win a prize, why in the second lottery you wont eliminated your posts?




*I know this don't give me a place or a gift but only want to know explanations.


This pretty much sums it up.

And Kariel, it may seem people are being mean to you specifically...but as you said, you are the face of the fansite. It is your job to take the abuse and the feedback with a smile and deal with it the best you can. I don't see Mirade etc complaining because people don't like something on Tibia. They don't always agree, sure, but they at least try to treat people with some respect and delicacy.

Posted by James Dark on 14 July 2012 13:09:35
#68

well looks like you didnt understood me
i want know why exactly i didnt got a single point

was it couse of the drawing? couse there was other pics that got points that was way worser

or was it couse i wrote only a small text?
this was a drawing contest not a writing contest if i aint missunderstood

so please tell me what exactly was wrong with my pic so i can make it next time better

Posted by Lizezzy on 14 July 2012 16:13:44
#69

Congratz peepz! :)
Wery nicely done!

Dramas are not needed, there are always people who are not happy with the results!
Nothing will be changed anyways, better luck next time!




L.

Edited by Lizezzy on 14 July 2012 16:14:59

Posted by Kariel Win on 14 July 2012 17:33:40
#70

James Dark wrote:
well looks like you didnt understood me
i want know why exactly i didnt got a single point

was it couse of the drawing? couse there was other pics that got points that was way worser

or was it couse i wrote only a small text?
this was a drawing contest not a writing contest if i aint missunderstood

so please tell me what exactly was wrong with my pic so i can make it next time better


You misunderstood so, because this was not only a drawing contest, that's why I ask for the person give a explanation of why the friend would be a good idea etc... That's the error of the people in thinking in this way, we evaluated the texts too.

Posted by Kariel Win on 14 July 2012 17:37:14
#71

This pretty much sums it up.

And Kariel, it may seem people are being mean to you specifically...but as you said, you are the face of the fansite. It is your job to take the abuse and the feedback with a smile and deal with it the best you can. I don't see Mirade etc complaining because people don't like something on Tibia. They don't always agree, sure, but they at least try to treat people with some respect and delicacy.


Respect we give for the people that honors and respect you too.

@Lizezzy

As the people saw, I'm not afraid in change results.
I'm just waiting the answers of 1 judge to make a new change.
I already join contests that after the results, It was proved the some of the winners used photoshop, illegal things that for the contests was not allowed. And you know what the admin did? Nothing, just ignore all, didn't reply and closed the thread, after weeks everybody "forgot" what happened.
That's why people are surprised and shocked, maybe they never saw the truth and the result changing in a contests; but here on Funtibia the things are a very different.

Posted by jeffstarchips on 14 July 2012 18:54:48
#72

Thanks FunTibia For the second place!
I worked a lot on my drawing. I had several ideas. I thought of many friends.
But when we participate in a contest you must read the rules well.
Do not you have won the competition, does not mean that his art was not good. For the idea also has to be good.
I understand that many may be sad about the result. I understand. I have attended several fan art contest and tibia did not win.
We must learn to respect the choices of judges. And try to improve and the next!

Thanks again for the opportunity Fun tibia. And I think the winners were fair and very creative!

Just want to confirm the Golden Emblem Sudden Death Rune SD
Black Scofield
Harmonia
Thais

Posted by Moon Day on 14 July 2012 19:02:30
#73

@Kariel Win:

Hi, i join on the choose a present contest. I've read all the post on this thread and i saw that you said that you delete some post. I was looking on the Choose a present thread and i dont found my post. So i want to know why did you delete my post?

I Said this on the post: "I choose my presence because whe we are sad and lonely the best thing is to be with friends."

I want to know too the reasons that made my post to be deleted.

Posted by Kariel Win on 14 July 2012 19:57:06
#74

Moon Day wrote:
@Kariel Win:

Hi, i join on the choose a present contest. I've read all the post on this thread and i saw that you said that you delete some post. I was looking on the Choose a present thread and i dont found my post. So i want to know why did you delete my post?

I Said this on the post: "I choose my presence because whe we are sad and lonely the best thing is to be with friends."

I want to know too the reasons that made my post to be deleted.


We was very light in the criteria and deleted the posts we don't consider it could be a present. We expected gifts and not a person as reward.

Posted by Emily Marie on 14 July 2012 22:06:55
#75

Kariel Win wrote:
This was not a contest to see who is the best designer, who made the best picture.


Im sorry but the first place should have been disqualified and you knwo it yourself. The nightmares are just cutted out with photoshop from the cipsoft teaser and turned liek you hold it infront of a mirrow.
And the Doll is aswell just copy pasted and a little shape over it so it looks not 100% same colour as the original one by Li Dao.

You said we can used exisiting monsters ye but existing paintings that we just fit together by copy paste and cut outs?
Lmao wheres the SELF MADE part your talking about then?

Idc if I won or not but there were more fair and better people around in the contest that deserve a Win.

And I doubt Cip with give rewards to rule breakers of a contest.

We as Tibianation Team had to kick out our Winner aswell cuz we later on got told it was a Copy of someone else.
So stick to your own made rules and disqualify at least the first place lol.
/read theres something with another winner too but dno about that one so w/e.

Posted by Mack Kard on 15 July 2012 03:01:43
#76

@Kariel Win:

I asked you only 3 things...
and I said "I just want to clarify, I do not expect to win something because i wasn't even close to it", I just want answers!
I believe I have not disrespected anyone, and therefore do not understand "why I have no answers"

OK, the contest is ended and the prizes was sent, but can you answer?

Posted by Moon Day on 15 July 2012 04:33:56
#77

@Kariel Win

Well i think that is unfair for me because you never tell that a person cant be a present. I dont see a rule that said that i can be disqualified if i choose a person for a present.

The rules said:


【ツ】 In this contest, you can make only 1 submission
【ツ】 You have to submit your works by the end of June
【ツ】 No multi accounts allowed
【ツ】 You must not break any rules of Tibia.com
【ツ】 Remember to post your character name and city that you would like to receive the prize (in case you win).
【ツ】If there are any changes in the rules, we will announce it in this thread
【ツ】You can participate in both contests. (“Best Friend” and “Choose a present”)
【ツ】If you break any rule, you will be disqualified from this contest
【ツ】Your text must be posted in English. (If you have any difficulty writing in English you can ask for our team to help you).
【ツ】The best answers will win a ticket to our lottery.

So im not mad at all but you could post a rule there saying that -.-

Posted by Kariel Win on 15 July 2012 17:58:14
#78

@Moon Day

So you the kind of person that go to a birthday party and say that your presence is the "present"?
LMAO:D:D

@Mack Kard
The things you asked it was already answered in other posts.

Edited by Kariel Win on 15 July 2012 18:00:08

Posted by Moon Day on 15 July 2012 19:30:42
#79

@Kariel Win

Yeah im the kind of person that do that.

But im disappointed because i should get a number on the lottery.

Posted by Kariel Win on 16 July 2012 07:20:46
#80

Moon Day wrote:
@Kariel Win

Yeah im the kind of person that do that.

But im disappointed because i should get a number on the lottery.


We don't consider that as a present, so no present = no ticket. Understand now why you didn't join the lottery?

Posted by Moon Day on 16 July 2012 08:00:42
#81

Yes i know, i just want to tell you that you did all wrong on this contest. You can't say that you don't consider that as a present because it is a present.

Have a lot of problems on this contest even with the choose a friend.

This is the worst contest i ever join. Change for the next contest because you'll need it.

Posted by Kariel Win on 16 July 2012 08:49:55
#82

Moon Day wrote:
Yes i know, i just want to tell you that you did all wrong on this contest. You can't say that you don't consider that as a present because it is a present.

Have a lot of problems on this contest even with the choose a friend.

This is the worst contest i ever join. Change for the next contest because you'll need it.


You are a nice joker :D

Posted by Yomomma on 16 July 2012 09:04:01
#83

This is best contest ever, who complains know not how real contest is, always leader decide ALL rules, if u dont like it why you join? noobs!

Edited by Yomomma on 16 July 2012 18:06:15

Posted by Moon Day on 16 July 2012 19:42:20
#84

@Yomomma:

Did you see a rule on the contest that say that i can't choose a person for a present?

Posted by Mack Kard on 17 July 2012 12:05:23
#85

lol
and the 3rd Place? oO

Posted by Luzei on 18 July 2012 07:04:58
#86

Why did you disqualify me? I didnt do anything

Posted by Kariel Win on 18 July 2012 16:11:49
#87

Luzei wrote:
Why did you disqualify me? I didnt do anything


Yes of course, you are really innocent (ironic)
Why you not happier now? We solved your problem, since you didn't was happy with the 3rd place.
:P:P
I should back to do my job.
Summarizing your disqualification, it's about the rule 2a and 2b.
The rules that have on Tibia.com also apply here on Funtibia.
Have fun!
Kariel

Posted by Luzei on 18 July 2012 19:17:12
#88

I have never broken any of the rules you stated above.
Yes, I did complain about how some things in the contest were vague and misleading but I never posted any insults towards you and neither did I spam you.
Please provide proves that your accuses above are correct , until then I will keep fighting for my rights in this contest.

Posted by Kariel Win on 18 July 2012 20:07:17
#89

Luzei wrote:
I have never broken any of the rules you stated above.
Yes, I did complain about how some things in the contest were vague and misleading but I never posted any insults towards you and neither did I spam you.
Please provide proves that your accuses above are correct , until then I will keep fighting for my rights in this contest.


Some people didn't believed on what I said, but after they hear the same things from Cip saw that was the truth. Many ppl can think that is unfair and insulted me, so for them read the reply sent by CIP.
Cip already told me the answers they give for the ppl that replied. And I dont know if you got that answers but I will copy some for you:

- There is no law that if a 2nd place gets disqualified, the third place
winner moves up to the second place. There are many possibilities to
deal with something like that. One option is that the other winners move
up one space, as participants suggested, another would be to simply have
no second place then at all, a third option is to re-evaluate winners -
and there are surely many others....


- I also told them that you have the right to exclude people from your
fansite, that you don't have to take insults,
however, that you should
try to maintain a friendly tone yourself, which I think you did here.


Somethings if you want to have, you should give too. So if you wanted my respect you should had give me respect. I never was disrespectful with you, and never created thread to say bad things about you, or a fansite.
I can assume that I'm being ironic with you, but never disrespectful.
And to end this...
Sorry but here on funtibia you will have nothing!

Peaces,
Kariel Win

Posted by Luzei on 18 July 2012 20:45:13
#90

Kariel Win wrote:
Luzei wrote:
I have never broken any of the rules you stated above.
Yes, I did complain about how some things in the contest were vague and misleading but I never posted any insults towards you and neither did I spam you.
Please provide proves that your accuses above are correct , until then I will keep fighting for my rights in this contest.


Some people didn't believed on what I said, but after they hear the same things from Cip saw that was the truth. Many ppl can think that is unfair and insulted me, so for them read the reply sent by CIP.
Cip already told me the answers they give for the ppl that replied. And I dont know if you got that answers but I will copy some for you:

- There is no law that if a 2nd place gets disqualified, the third place
winner moves up to the second place. There are many possibilities to
deal with something like that. One option is that the other winners move
up one space, as participants suggested, another would be to simply have
no second place then at all, a third option is to re-evaluate winners -
and there are surely many others....


- I also told them that you have the right to exclude people from your
fansite, that you don't have to take insults,
however, that you should
try to maintain a friendly tone yourself, which I think you did here.


Somethings if you want to have, you should give too. So if you wanted my respect you should had give me respect. I never was disrespectful with you, and never created thread to say bad things about you, or a fansite.
I can assume that I'm being ironic with you, but never disrespectful.
And to end this...
Sorry but here on funtibia you will have nothing!

Peaces,
Kariel Win


If you're talking about my thread on the tibia.com forums breaking any of the rules you are wrong. Why you might ask? WELL because if they broke any rules I would have been banished or at least been getting a notation, I did not. You said Your rules are the same as Tibia.com rules..
so I'm just asking you again, where is the proves of me to get disqualified for the contest, or is this all just about you not being able to take some normal criticism?

I believe you took it personal :s

Posted by lekiro on 18 July 2012 22:41:36
#91

She never insulted you. Questioning results is something you should accept. It is a valid way to express your opinion. If you cant handle such crticism then I have to tell you to grow up and stop being a kid.

She never spammed either btw.

So sorry to tell you, but you are just giving cheap excuses to disqualify someone who tried to raise her voice.

Be sure that after this stupid mistake you are making people will remember your actions. And probably ruin your further contests.

Posted by Fenelez on 19 July 2012 07:18:12
#92

I confirm that my information is

Character: Warrior
World: Antica
City: Venore

With best regards from Fenelez.

Posted by jeffstarchips on 19 July 2012 18:51:36
#93

Cm Rejana just sends them

FUNTIBIA Thanks again!

img834.imageshack.us/img834/1010/tibiafun.jpg

Posted by Lady Tynha on 19 July 2012 20:20:11
#94

Pffff always someone unhappy with the result.People really don't know to lose...Haters gonna hate :P HAHA
Congratz for the winners and for FunTibia! 2 years <3 #xoxo

Posted by Yomomma on 19 July 2012 20:43:09
#95

haters gonna hate, nonpvpers gonna nonpvp

Posted by lekiro on 20 July 2012 04:30:54
#96

Yomomma wrote:
haters gonna hate, nonpvpers gonna nonpvp


junkchars gonna post.

Your char was created 16/07... I wouldnt like to speculate who you really are, it could get me a new warning lol

btw, thanks for warning. Did I say something that hurt your feelings? What rule did i break?

Oh ye I know, rule 6a: "do not criticize fansite admins' poor judgement"

And now I'm breaking rule 2h: "do not make sarcastic comments on a fansite that has "fun" in its name"

OMG, I just broke that last rule twice :(